We Report, That is All

by
posted on May 19, 2014
wereport.jpg

On our June cover, we ran the Remington R51 9 mm semi-automatic pistol. The coverage was provided by our Ammo Editor, Richard Mann, one of the foremost gunwriters on the planet. I'm not going to give away what he said about the pistol. What I'd like to discuss is the virulent hatred this pistol has engendered on social media.

Many of the comments on our Facebook page when we provided a photo of the R51 from the magazine accused us of running "just bought and paid for advertising," only positive reviews and selling out to advertisers. I understand the sentiment, since sometimes we do review firearms made by advertisers, but that is not what drives our coverage.

I don't think anyone would dispute the R51 is worthy of coverage. It is an interesting design from one of the oldest and largest gun makers on the planet, and it is that company's first pistol chambered in 9 mm. You needn't like a gun to think it worthy of attention.

What's more, by covering a gun, we are not demanding you go out and purchase one. We provide one person's opinion of the single example they received for testing, along with shooting results using an apples-to-apples protocol so the gun in question can be compared to other similar guns we review. As a more famous entity says: "We report, you decide."

Simply put, the R51 was a major introduction for 2014 worthy of coverage by any outlet. We provided an honest review from someone who knows what he's writing about. If other individuals experienced difficulty with their R51s, that is certainly something they should report, but again, the reason they are reporting on it at all is because the gun is interesting and worthy of coverage.

I am confident we provided an honest review of the R51 based on Mann's testing. Others may have had a different experience. That's fine. No gun is perfect, and nowhere do we say the R51 is perfect.

We report honestly, and do so whether a company advertises with us or not. Period.

Latest

Vaultek D2Si
Vaultek D2Si

First Look: Vaultek DS2i Smart Station

A full-featured compact safe to securely store your valuables.

Does Birdshot Overpenetrate?

Home defenders sometimes opt for birdshot, thinking it won’t overpenetrate. We put this concept to the test.

First Look: Rival Arms X1 Red Dot Sight

A new optic from a company known for their pistol upgrades.

Review: Safariland GLS Pro-Fit IWB Holster

A new concealed carry holster with built-in Level 2 retention.

First Look: Shadow Systems CR920P Pistol

A subcompact 9mm pistol with a removable compensator, which doesn't have a threaded barrel.

I Carry Spotlight: New for 2023 CZ 75 A01 SD Optics Ready Pistol

In today's I Carry spotlight we take a look at the New-for-2023 CZ 75 A01 SD Optics Ready pistol.

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.