No Clearance for Clarence (or Bob)

by
posted on January 30, 2015
clearnce.jpg

A difference of 0.080 inch to 0.100 inch in the barrel-lug channel of a Government model frame prevents compatibility with Commander-length components.

After placing the barrel in the Caspian slide and locking the bushing in place, I added a Sprinco guide rod, recoil spring and plug atop my Essex frame. The problem came once I added the slide-stop pin and eased the slide forward. Despite the barrel and slide appearing to be totally forward or in "battery," a portion of the guide rod's tip protruded from the slide, which prevented the barrel bushing from turning fully to capture the compressed recoil spring and plug.

Suspecting something was out of spec with the rod, I removed the guide rod and attempted to replace it with another one from one of my Colt Combat Commanders only to make the same startling discovery. Forgoing the guide rod for a traditional recoil-spring guide and plug didn't work either. No matter what I tried, the slide would not go back far enough to lock the slide rearward. Could the recoil spring be too long? Swapping it with one from another one of my carry pistols confirmed I was barking up the wrong tree.

Consulting the troubleshooting section of my Kuhnhausen shop manual, DVDs and other reference materials yielded no clues. So, I got on the phone to consult with my various contacts within the industry—the majority of which shared equally in my frustration but were equally stumped—that is with the exception of Gary Smith of Caspian Arms. He asked me if my Essex frame was for a Government model of a Commander. I replied by telling him I'd had it for so long I couldn't remember, only to add I thought Government models and Commanders utilized the same frame. I was wrong. It turns out when Colt originally produced the Commander back in 1950 it machined the barrel-lug channel approximately 0.080- to 0.100-inch deeper than that of a Government model. While Smith commended me for wanting to utilize my Essex frame, his solution was to switch to a Caspian frame. Since I don't have access to a mill to alter the barrel-lug channel of the Essex frame, I agreed.

The new frame eventually arrived, along with a Foster Industries government-model slide, and suddenly my one-pistol build transformed into a two-pistol build. Suddenly, I found myself  back at square one, without passing "Go" (or collecting $200) which subsequently sent the budget build out the window.

Latest

pile of firearm magazines
pile of firearm magazines

How Durable Are Your Magazines?

Regardless of where you go for firearm information, some form of gun testing is likely to figure into the results you dig up. Consumer appetites for this information are just as vigorous as in other industries.

First Look: Alien Gear Swivel Drop Leg Extension

Get your holster out of the way while still keeping your pistol at the ready.

Mantis X10 Elite Review

Make dry practice at home more fun, and save money and time when you go to the range.

The Pros and Cons Of Red Dot Sight On Your Shotgun

Red-dot sights are all the rage. Should you put one on your home-defense shotgun?

First Look: Viridian Laser for the Heritage Rough Rider Revolver

A laser sight for a single action revolver makes for a terrific training aid.

Learn to Search Slow & Carefully

Haste makes waste. Worse still, it could make the difference between life and death.

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.