Holster Review: Aker FlatSider XR12

posted on February 22, 2020

One of the dilemmas every concealed carrier faces is the choice between IWB and OWB. It’s not a fashion debate, but rather an issue of printing. It’s easier to tuck away a holster and gun that don’t hang off your belt, adding extra bulge and possibly peeking out from under the edge of the cover garment. It’s a practical matter, one not to take lightly if you believe in the saying “If they know you’re concealing, you’re doing it wrong.”

I’ve always been a big fan of IWB for 90 percent of the year, the part when a heavy coat is not appropriate. For summertime carry, especially, OWB is just too bulky for most of what I wear. So, when Aker sent me an OWB holster to review, I almost gave it back. But I decided to give it a fair shake, especially since it was winter and I could probably hide it well enough if I planned my wardrobe right. Plus, I was concealing a Shield 9 mm, which is easy to hide because of its size.

The FlatSider XR12 is a molded leather holster with two features not often found on leather holsters. First is a retention screw right beneath the trigger guard cover just like a kydex holster. I was very surprised to find this nice feature. Immediately, I safely cleared my gun, inserted it into the holster and performed the flip test. The gun stayed put. I shook it and it still stayed. For fun, I played with the retention, which adjusts with a flathead screwdriver, and found it easy to use.

The second feature that surprised me was a thumb break, a mechanism typically found on duty rigs. When is the last time you saw one of those on a civilian CCW holster? It had been a while for me. But this one had it, so I figured I better try it. I ran the leather slots through my trusty gun belt, snugged it against my waist and noticed that the holster held tight despite my fear that the thumb break might make the whole setup too thick. Next, I added the gun and snapped it closed. The thumb break worked flawlessly, thanks to a thin metal stiffener in the vertical snap receiver. Again, with a dry gun, I practiced draws and re-holsters, all of which worked perfectly, no problem clearing through the extra leather.

Then it came time for the big test. Winter chill called for a sweatshirt that was big enough to cover the bottom of the holster with zero print. I wore the holster all day during my normal activities and never once worried about it sneaking out from under cover. And talk about comfortable. The leather was stiff enough to hold the gun securely, but soft enough to contour to me like silk. I wore it several more times to see if my good experience could be repeated and was not disappointed.

The FlatSider XR12 comes in black and brown leather options and runs $81.50 on Aker’s website. If you prefer OWB and are a fan of leather holsters, this is a terrific option.


RCBS Chargemaster Supreme
RCBS Chargemaster Supreme

High-Tech Handloading

I now keep all my ammunition-creation data on a computer. Sure, I’ll make notes when working up a new load or tweaking an existing one, but ultimately my data is stored digitally. Since my loading room is only steps from my computer, the transition from written to digital data has been easy for me. Now that I’m using the handloading app from RCBS, it’s even easier, and it also makes recreating my favorite loads when I’m at the loading bench more convenient.

First Look: 1791 Gunleather Holsters for S&W CSX Pistols

New holsters for the nifty little pistol from Smith & Wesson.

First Look: XS Night Sights for SA XD OSP and Tisas PX-9

Two new front and rear sight sets featuring some of XS Sights most popular designs.

Concealed-Carry Contemplations

You took a concealed-carry class from a well-known instructor who visited your local range recently. You learned a lot—especially that there was a lot yet to learn—over the two days of the course.

What We Plan For

Sheriff Jim reminds us that wishing and hopeful thinking should not be part of your self-defense plan.

First Look: GiantMouse ACE Nazca Knives

A folding knife with south of the border style.


Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.