posted on August 10, 2015
sheriff-jim-5-28-15.jpg (5)

The handgun is of value as a defensive tool only because it is relatively easy to carry on your person all day long. However, during a home invasion, or other criminal attack, your chances of surviving go up considerably if you can get some sort of long gun into action. The simple reason is that, under a criminal attack, none of us shoot as well as do in a practice session at the range.

This was driven home to me a few months back when I was asked to escort a fellow to a particularly remote region of the Rio Grande. This wasn't pistol country, though I had one, it was rifle country. Fortunately, I have a .308 Ruger Scout Rifle that handles very nicely in and out of my Jeep and is quite accurate. Oh, we didn't get into one of those exciting adventures but you can bet that carbine felt comforting as we explored the desert canyons in the area.

During my law enforcement career I had an opportunity to become familiar with the various AR's and they deserve the popularity that they currently enjoy. At present, besides the Ruger Scout, I am testing Mossberg's version of the Scout rifle for a Shooting Illustrated article. In addition, I have a Ruger Tactical Mini-14 that pretty well lives in my vehicle.

My point is this, where defensive carbines are concerned, we live in a time of plenty. The defensive shooter is bound to find one that shoots well for him, meets his needs, and fits his budget. Whether you end up with an AR, an AK, a Mini-14, one of the various Scout rifles, or some other carbine variation, is really immaterial. The test is that you shoot it well, that it is reliable, and that it meets your needs.

So, by all means, continue to carry and practice with your defensive pistol, but have a fall-back plan. Defensive carbines are just dandy fall-back plans.


Gatorz Laser Defender
Gatorz Laser Defender

First Look: Gatorz Laser Defender

Protect your eyes from damage from more than one source of light.

There Is No Sanctuary

Carrying a defensive pistol inside the home should be the same as carrying one outside of the home.

First Look: Federal Premium Force X2 Shorty 00 Buckshot

A new option in 1¾-inch defensive shotgun ammunition.

First Look: ZeroTech Thrive HD First Focal Plane Riflescopes

Two new ruggedized scopes from the land down under.

Review: We the People IWB Holster and Tactical Gun Belt

A kydex holster and gun belt designed for no-nonsense everyday use.

I Carry: Walther WMP 22 WMR Pistol in a PHLster Holster

Today on I Carry we have the new Walther WMP pistol chambered in 22 WMR, carried in a PHLster Floodlight holster along with an SOG Power Access Deluxe multi-tool.


Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.