Range Review: Springfield Armory XD-S Mod.2 in 9 mm

posted on August 1, 2018

There’s an old cliché in the gunwriter world that “a .22 on you beats a .45 in your truck,” and like most clichés, it has a ring of truth to it. Having a gun on you when you need it the most is far, far more preferable than trying to call a “time out” in the middle of a armed violent encounter, so having a gun, ANY gun puts you way ahead of the game when it matters the most. This is big reason why single-stack 9 mm pistols like the Springfield Armory XD-S Mod.2 have recently become so popular: Because they so lightweight, slim and easy to conceal compared to a full-sized, full-capacity service pistol, they are a much lighter burden to carry compared to a bigger gun. Yes, there is a tradeoff in capacity and a slight tradeoff in accuracy, but with practice, these can be managed, and a single stack 9 mm becomes a viable choice for a self-defense gun.

Springfield Armory saw the benefits of single stack 9 mm early on, and for some time now, the company's XD-S pistol has been a great choice for someone looking to buy a small, easy-to-carry 9 mm pistol. But even great choices can get better, and Springfield Armory has recently announced the 9 mm XD-S Mod.2, with a number of significant improvements.

The frame for the XD-S MOD2 is reshaped and re-textured from the original XD-S. The stippling on the frame is no longer rows of raised dots, but rather more like the grip tape used by some competition shooters to give them a better hold on their guns. The shape of the grip itself is changed, allowing for a higher grip on the gun, which allows for better recoil control (a handy little feature in a gun this size). The trigger guard is also undercut to allow for a higher grip, and overall, I found the XD-S to be noticeably easier to shoot than its predecessor.

The XD-S Mod.2 ships with one seven-round magazine with a extension for your little finger to rest on, and a nine-round extended magazine. I found the seven-round magazine to be a bit too short to get a full firing grip on the pistol, and the nine-round magazine was a bit too long to carry in the gun without it showing up as I carried it concealed. However, Springfield Armory also shipped out an additional eight-round magazine with my test gun and that magazine was a nice balance between concealability and ammo capacity. Unfortunately, Springfield does not include the eight-round magazine with the gun when it ships from the factory. You'll have to buy it separately.

The rear of the slide on the XD-S Mod.2 has serrations that are cut deeper and longer than the original XD-S, and I found them to be easy to grip and use to get the pistol into action. The sights on the model I tested featured a tritium luminescent front sight and a serrated rear sight, which I found to be easy to use and helped get me on target quickly and accurately.

On the range, the XD-S Mod.2 was easy to shoot and pointed naturally in my hand. I’m a big fan of the single-stack 9mm as a day-in, day-out carry gun, and the XD-S Mod.2 shoots as well as any other subcompact 9 mm I’ve shot. The controls of the gun are logically placed and easy to access quickly, and the gun was comfortable in my hands, even after a 200-round practice session.

The trigger on the XD-S Mod.2 has noticeable take-up and some stacking, and breaks at just over 7 pounds, after which there is about a half-inch of reset travel and a very distinct reset. While that’s not match-trigger performance, it’s quite adequate for a concealed-carry gun, and the trigger had no noticeable effect on my accuracy with the pistol. Trigger pull weight, measured with a Lyman Trigger Pull Gauge, averaged 6.86 pounds.

Overall, the XD-S Mod.2 is real contender in the single-stack 9 mm game. With its slim frame, excellent sights and comfortable ergonomics, it makes a great little pistol for concealed carry, especially when using either the seven-round or eight-round magazine. If home defense is your concern, the nine-round extended length magazine gives you added firepower, and frame accessory rail lets you add a wide variety of lights, lasers and other accessories that will help you make the shot when it counts the most. The suggested MSRP on the Springfield Armory XD-S Mod.2 9 mm starts at $524.



Stoeger STR 9SC 9 mm Optic Ready
Stoeger STR 9SC 9 mm Optic Ready

New for 2022: Stoeger STR Handgun Line Expands

The STR-9SC Sub-Compact series meets the needs of today's concealed carrier with models featuring tritium sights and an optics-ready slide while keeping price to a minimum.

New for 2022: SureFire New Turbo Series Handheld Lights and Weaponlights

Thanks to end-user feedback, SureFire has improved upon its Turbo series of handheld lights and weaponlights, offering improved performance with the same craftmanship and durability consumers have come to expect from the brand.

New for 2022: POF-USA Phoenix

Brand-new from the ground up, the POF-USA Phoenix is a large-format handgun with a host of user-friendly features, including the ability to mount a pistol brace or a sling, a mil-spec AR-15 trigger, a Mission First Tactical grip and an M-Lok-compatible handguard.

New for 2022: Heritage Mfg. Rough Rider TC

While one might not expect to find a threaded muzzle, Picatinny rail and fiber-optic sights on an Old West-style, single-action revolver, that's exactly what Heritage Manufacturing did with its new Rough Rider TC (Tactical Cowboy).

2021 Sets 2nd-Highest Gun Sales Mark

The total number of 2021 firearm purchases processed through the FBI’s National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) was the second highest on record.

Editor’s Picks: SHOT Show 2022, Day Two

It's Day Two of SHOT Show 2022, and we find another five cool things we saw while walking the show floor.


Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.