Judge Nixes AG's Request in Gun Purchase Waiting Period Case

by
posted on December 1, 2014
sinews.jpg (151)

A ruling in California Federal Court has moved gun owners one step closer to being able to take possession of legally purchased firearms without waiting ten days if they have a concealed weapons permit or have gone through the purchase process in the past.

In a new order released Nov. 20, Federal District Court Judge Anthony W. Ishii rejected two requests made by California Attorney General Kamala Harris in Silvester, et al. v. Harris, originally filed in Fresno Dec. 23, 2011.

Judge Ishii ruled in August that California's law requiring existing gun owners to comply with the ten-day waiting period was unconstitutional per the Second Amendment. While first-time gun buyers are still subject to the 10-day waiting period, Judge Ishii ruled that those who have already been judged competent to own a gun should not be forced to wait an additional period for every new gun they seek to purchase.

"The Second Amendment applies to 'arms' and its language does not limit its full protections to a single firearm," Judge Ishii wrote. "Some firearms are better suited for particular lawful purposes than others. Defendant has cited no authority that suggests that the Second Amendment only has application to a single firearm."

At the time of his August 25 judgment, the judge stayed his own ruling for 180 days to give state time to rewrite its laws, should it choose to do so. California Attorney General Kamala Harris subsequently filed motions to stay and to alter judgment, both which Judge Ishii denied last week.

"The Court notes that Defendant has not identified any error of law or any erroneous factual finding," Judge Ishii explained in his denial of Harris' requests. "The Court stands by its analysis and its findings that the waiting period laws violate the Second Amendment" as applied to the three classes of individuals that, plaintiffs successfully argued, shouldn't be subject to the laws.

AG Harris has already filed a notice with the district court that she intends to appeal to the Ninth Circuit Court.

Latest

Savage Stance XR
Savage Stance XR

First Shots: Savage Stance XR

Savage's micro-9 mm pistol gets an optics cut and double-stack magazine.

SHOT 2025 Roundup: Night Vision/Thermal Optics

The world of low light gets more popular every day.

First Shots: Mossberg 590RM Shotgun

Magazine-fed with an ambidextrous, frame-mounted safety.

Shot Show 2025 Editor's Picks: Day One

What caught our attention during the opening day of SHOT Show 2025.

SHOT 2025 Roundup: Pistol Red Dot Sights

Pistol-mounted dots continue to be extremely popular.

First Look: Aridus Industries Imperium Tactical Handguard for the Beretta 1301

An aluminum handguard for a popular tactical shotgun.

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.