3 Self-Defense Opinions That Don't Hold Water

by
posted on September 13, 2019
sheriff-jim-5-28-15.jpg (32)

Too often, especially on social media, we hear people touting defensive techniques and opinions that, upon further examination, simply don’t hold water. In short, it turns out that they have come up with some bogus idea about personal defense to cover up their own shortcomings. The have developed what I call a defensive crutch.

One example would be the claim that some defense guns just don’t hold enough ammunition. Many if not most citizen-involved self-defense shootings may be resolved with the ammunition that the citizen has in his or her gun. Our internet experts will, however, claim that you should never carry a defense gun that doesn’t hold at least X–number of rounds. Armed citizens, of course, should be free to carry however many rounds of ammunition that they want to and think they might need. In fact, there are certainly situations where having more ammunition could turn out to be vital. The mistake is to think that lots of ammunition will make up for a lack of professional training or paying due attention to the need to improve one’s marksmanship skills. When that is the underlying motive, the whole concept becomes a defensive crutch. 

Another comment that makes me chuckle is the claim that people use their pistol only to fight their way to a rifle or shotgun. Again, studying citizen-involved gunfights, the fight is nearly always over before a person would have time to get to that long gun. We know that when people deploy a long gun, their chances of survival go way up. But that long gun is going to have to be pretty close–within reach–or the fight will be over. It would behoove that particular defensive shooter to spend more time improving his or her skills with a defensive handgun. And, of course, the worst defensive crutch belongs to those who don’t always carry their handgun but put it on when they think they will need it. All I can say is that their crystal ball must work better than mine does. 

In fact, we never know when or where a criminal attack will come. Armed citizens are smart to wear their defensive handgun whenever and wherever they can legally do so. And it is further well advised to avoid those places where such carry is prohibited. To think that we can predict the time and place of a criminal attack is another of those defensive crutches that we should avoid.

Readers will likely think of other examples of the defensive crutch that they have heard. The main thing is for each of us to examine our own defensive plan and get rid of those defensive crutches that have a nasty way of sneaking in. Good professional training and then practicing what we have learned will go a long way toward developing a useful personal-defense plan and avoiding defensive crutches.

Latest

camera
camera

How to Improve Home Defense with a Security Camera

Adding a security camera you can monitor from your smartphone can help create a layered defense system for your home and provide advanced notice of a potential threat.

First Look: Bear Edge 61123 Knife

Bear Edge Knives makes affordable-priced knives for everyday use and carry, and now for 2021 they are introducing the new Bear Edge 61123.

First Look: Bushmaster Bravo Zulu Rifles

Bushmaster recently launched its Bravo Zulu line of AR-15 rifles, which will be available in five different configurations. 

Barrett Produces 1,000th MRAD MK22

The 1,000th MRAD (Multi-Role Adaptive Design) Mark 22 MOD 0 (MK22) rifle destined for use in the United States Special Operations Command (USSOCOM) Advanced Sniper Rifle and United States Army Precision Sniper Rifle programs rolled out of Barrett Firearms Manufacturing in November.

Silencer Central Cyber Monday Sale

Silencer Central's Cyber Monday Sale allows customers who buy a Banish .223, Banish 30, Banish 30 Gold, or Banish 45 to receive a Banish 22K, a titanium rimfire silencer that weighs in at 2.45 ounces, for free.

First Look: Springfield Armory Ronin EMP

Springfield Armory recently announced the newest addition to its award-winning family of 1911s with the Ronin EMP.

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.