Why, Full-Length Guide Rod? Why?

by
posted on November 28, 2011
wilson2015_fs.jpg (7)

The best I can find out, the full-length guide rod was adopted for the 1911 pistol by competition shooters around the time gamesmen began to take over IPSC competition. I have found it interesting to ask those who use the device to explain just what it does to improve the function and/or accuracy of the 1911. Manufacturers and shooters alike tend to respond with vague explanations that are not founded in facts or sound reasoning.

Some will tell you it improves accuracy. Others will share the fact that it keeps the recoil spring from kinking when the action cycles. Still others will declare that it gives a little extra weight to the muzzle end of the pistol, slightly dampening recoil and allowing the handgun to get back on target more quickly.

A few years back, an in-depth study of the full-length guide rod was undertaken. Guns were fired from a Ransom Rest with and without the part. It was clearly shown the full-length guide rod had nothing to do with a particular pistol's accuracy or reliability. And we have known for some time that a strong isometric hold on the pistol is the best way to control muzzle flip and allow us to get back on target as quickly as possible. About the only thing a full-length guide rod accomplishes is to make an easy-to-disassemble pistol more difficult to disassemble. The value of this escapes me.

Somewhere along the line, however, some 1911 manufacturers decided including a full-length guide rod on their pistols gave them a "custom" look. Put three-dot sights and a full-length guide rod on the gun, and you can charge more for it. It's almost like, if you don't know what you're doing, it's even more important to look cool. For goodness sakes, don't ever ask why.

Latest

Lew Walt in uniform
Lew Walt in uniform

Fightin' Iron: Lew Walt

Helicopters make a distinctive sound. It’s sort of a whop-whop noise, and it differs a little from one chopper model to the next. The Vietnam War was the first true helicopter war. Early on, our primary troop carrier was the CH-34. We also had an observation outfit flying the UH-1Es (a variant of the legendary “Huey”).

The Best Apps for Shooting Enthusiasts

There’s more computing power in your smartphone or tablet than Apollo 11 had on board when it landed on the moon. Today’s handheld devices perform complex calculations weighted for environmental variables—in real time—and provide solutions at lightning speed. The technology is staggering, but not all of today’s firearm apps are about ballistics.

First Look: Walker's ATACS Sport Earbuds

Walker’s is known as a leader in hearing protection and enhancement and now they are releasing their most ergonomic electronic sound management system yet for shooters and hunters.

Silencer Central Announces New Website

Silencer Central has debuted a new website and logo. The redesigned site further streamlines the buying experience and provides more versatile tools for suppressor education and enhanced customer service.

5 Great Upgrades for Subcompact Pistols

The following products help to customize subcompact defensive handguns to better suit your needs.

Point Shooting Vs. Sighted Fire: Which is Better?

The battle rages on between point shooters and those who rely on sighted fire. Is there a true winner in that contest?

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.