If It Ain't Broke...

posted on May 15, 2014
wilson2015_fs.jpg (14)

When I was a young man, quite a few Texas Rangers and border lawmen still carried the Colt Single Action Army revolver. Hearing from readers today, I find that there are still some folks who rely on a single-action for personal defense. People who are new to personal-defense handguns may find it hard to believe that many defensive shooters are still carrying double-action revolvers (a design that is well over 100 years old), 1911 single-action semi-automatics (103 years old) and the Browning Hi Power (almost 80 years old).

One of the main reasons is older shooters are comforted to carry handguns that have saved their lives in the past. It is hard to quit winners. And one should not discount those years of contact with a certain handgun design, in which the shooters have learned the gun's operation intimately. You often hear the comment, "I could field strip it in the dark." In times of great stress it is comforting to be armed with a firearm that you know everything about.

And there are new shooters who come along and decide that if a certain gun design has worked for people over all these years, it must be good. I have always liked the fact that the 1911 .45 ACP was battle-tested successfully long before I ever laid hands on one. Conversely, I have always thought it was a really bad idea to have to be the first one to test a new gun design in an actual gunfight. Too many bad things can happen.

Today we are blessed with a wonderful assortment of handguns that may be suitable for personal defense. And none of my remarks lauding the praises of the older designs should be taken to mean that I am against new gun design. I wouldn't have the job I have if that were the case.

The smart thing is to experiment with a broad assortment of defensive handguns until you find the one that is best suited your needs. Old or new, it really doesn't matter as long as you find what really works for you. Once you do find that perfect defensive handgun, buy it, no matter what the cost. In fact, buy two or three so you'll have some spares. The important thing to remember is that personal defense guns shouldn't be some sort of fashion fad, where you run out and get whatever is new. Do whatever it takes to get what works for you and then stick with it.

One of these days, if you're lucky to live long enough, you'll be saying, "Why should I give up this old pistol for something new? It has saved my life and we have a history." In other words, if it ain't broke, don't fix it!


I Carry: Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 Compact
I Carry: Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 Compact

I Carry: Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 Compact Pistol in a Tulster Holster

In this week's episode of "I Carry," we have a Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 pistol carried in a Tulster Profile+ holster along with a C&H Precision Weapons Comp red-dot sight.

First Look: X-Vision Optics Thermal Scopes

Three new models to fit a variety of price points and needs.

First Look: Versacarry OWB Holster for The Taurus Judge

A leather belt holster that includes a built-in retention screw. 

In Memoriam: Melvin Forbes

An iconic gunmaker and the founder of Ultra Light Arms.

First Look: Primary Arms SLx 1-6x24 SFP ACSS Nova 5.56/.308 BDC Scope

A second-focal-plane LVPO that's a first rate value. 

Tactical … Hunting?

Think hunting and defensive practice are worlds apart? They’re closer than you think.


Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.