Injunction Issued in Maryland 'Shall Issue' Ruling

by
posted on July 26, 2012
sinews.jpg (194)

U.S. District Court Judge Benson E. Legg struck down the "good and substantial" requirement as unconstitutional in a March ruling, but temporarily delayed implementation of the decision pending a potential appeal and a subsequent stay by the state's attorney general's office.

But in an eight-page memorandum signed Monday, Legg ruled there was no basis for a stay and issued an order dissolving the temporary delay, effective 14 days from the ruling.

As a result, barring further court action by Maryland Attorney General Douglas F. Ganser's office, beginning August 8, Maryland will become a "shall issue" state, allowing residents to receive permits to carry concealed weapons for personal protection once basic safety and required law-enforcement criteria are met.

Prior to Legg's March 2012 ruling, Maryland was among only a few states adhering to a "may issue" policy for CCW permits, leaving the distribution up to the arbitrary discretion of county sheriffs, state police or other local authorities.

The original lawsuit was filed against the state in 2010 by Raymond Woollard, who was issued a Maryland permit to carry a concealed weapon in 2003 but was denied a renewal in 2009 by the Maryland State Police and the Handgun Permit Review Board, alleging Wollard failed to "verify threats beyond his residence."

Woollard's suit claimed the rejection was unconstitutional, and Legg ruled in his favor, finding Maryland's "good and substantial reason" requirement had no purpose other than to reduce the number of firearms in public while ignoring whether applicants are fit to carry them and that it "impermissibly infringes the right to keep and bear arms" as guaranteed by the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

"A citizen may not be required to offer a 'good and substantial reason' why he should be permitted to exercise his rights," Legg wrote. "The right's existence is all the reason he needs."

In 2011, Maryland State Police received 5,216 applications for CCW permits, rejecting about 5 percent. Most of those rejected—179 out of 251—were based on the "may issue" statute.

Latest

Taurus Defender .357 Mag.
Taurus Defender .357 Mag.

New for 2022: Taurus Defender .357 Mag. Revolver

Taurus improved upon its popular Model 605 with practical, concealed-carry-oriented features. The Defender features a longer barrel and enhanced sights than the original Model 605.

New for 2022: Blackhawk Adds Concealed-Carry Options

Blackhawk added to its Stache line with two new off-body carry options designed for comfort and concealment.

New for 2022: Taurus G3X Hybrid Compact Pistol

Taurus, listening to customer feedback, introduced the new G3X pistol, which falls between a compact and a full-size.

New for 2022: Bushnell Introduces Two New Micro Red-Dot Sights

Bushnell introduced the new RXC-200 and RXU-200 MRDS optics at the 2022 SHOT Show.

New For 2022: Winchester Ammunition Expands USA Ready Lineup

Winchester Ammunition expanded its popular, affordable USA Ready line with three new calibers in both competition and defense loads.

Six New Rifles from SHOT Show 2022

Contributor Frank Melloni scoured Industry Day at the Range at SHOT Show 2022 for cool new rifles. Here are six that caught his attention.

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.