Light Right

Does a flashlight really belong on your defensive handgun?

By Sheriff Jim Wilson (RSS)
August 21, 2012

One of the greatest aids to personal protection in recent years has been the advent of tough, compact, high-intensity flashlights we generally call defensive lights. Back in my law enforcement days we wagged around those big old flashlights that were great in a donnybrook but, otherwise, just got in the way. Nowadays, I seldom go anywhere without my little SureFire illuminator stuck somewhere about my person. Compact, handheld flashlights are useful, and I like them a lot.

However, I think installing such a light on your defensive handgun is a mistake. It changes the balance of the gun, while making it heavier and more difficult to conceal.

Folks will eventually get used to the change in balance, but this business of weight is another issue entirely. The most common complaint I hear about defensive handguns is they are heavy and uncomfortable to carry for extended periods. While I have carried a .45 Government Model or a Commander all day, every day, I hear this complaint so often that there must be something to it. A lot of people who are not used to wearing a gun all day long just seem to have a difficult time getting used to that weight. So, why would you make it heavier by adding a light?

Concealment is also an issue with gun-mounted lights. It is more difficult to find suitable holsters that accommodate a defensive light. And that light, and the bigger holster, add to the bulk that one has to conceal under his clothes. Yes, it can be done, but it requires a lot of experimenting, trial and error.

It is much easier to carry the defensive light separate from the pistol yet still on your person. You can then use it, or not use it, as the situation dictates. There are several simple techniques for using a handheld light in conjunction with a pistol, and with practice, you’re sure to find a method that works for you.

Defensive handgun trainer Louis Awerbuck put it so eloquently when he said, “Don’t hang stuff on your pistol!” Actually, he used another word that begins with “s” instead of “stuff,” but I think you get the picture.

However, there are exceptions to every rule. I think a handgun-mounted light makes a lot of sense when installed on a designated car gun or house gun, because these are not being worn and concealed all day long. We don’t care what they weigh and, in fact, when the balloon goes up you won’t give a moment’s thought to the issue of weight.

Of course, you are responsible for your own safety, so you should do what you think is best. Just don’t follow fad for the sake of being stylish. Give your light some thought, and fight smart.

Tags: , , , , ,


Comments

5 Responses to Light Right

  1. Pingback: SayUncle » Does a flashlight really belong on your defensive handgun?

  2. Armed Partisan says:

    I have a couple guns with rails, and on one of them, I have a flashlight mounted. It’s a Glock 17L with a 6″ barrel, so it’s not my carry gun. It’s a bump-in-the-night-gun for when I hear a noise outside at night. I don’t want my neighbors seeing me walk around with a rifle at night, so a pistol gives me plausible deniability, and plenty of ammo.

    Since this is a bedside gun, the extra bulk doesn’t matter, and I feel that most people don’t buy full size handguns for EDC, and most officers and duty personnel likely have a belt that such things can be attached to when the gun is holstered, or use is not necessary. Extra weight on the gun can’t be that big a problem, since it’s literally against the rules in IDPA to use anything which adds weight to the gun, since that can increase controlability under rapid firing scenarios.

  3. The crimson trace lightguard weighs 1.2oz, doesn’t increase the length or width of the pistol, and allows you to see the profile of your sights in low light. There is no reason not to have one on your compact or larger handgun (other than they don’t make one for it yet).

    If your carrying a sub-compact a laser is going to be more use.

    If you think the light adds too much bulk… you have the wrong light.

  4. Clay says:

    I have to agree with Rob. What lights are you talking about that are increasing the weight of the weapon to make it uncarryable? My current EDC is a Steyr M9-A1 with a TLR-1 on it. Yes, the holster is a little wider but it is by no means uncomfortable. Why have to occupy your reaction hand with your flashlight when you could have both hands on your weapon?

    I know the arguments about sweeping the target of your light so please don’t use that one.

  5. Pingback: White light or Red? | When the Balloon Goes Up!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>